The Status Question
Puerto Rico is a territory of the United States. The U.S. acquired Puerto Rico from Spain in 1898, and the Island has belonged to the United States ever since. In 1917, Puerto Ricans became U.S. citizens. Everyone born in Puerto Rico is a citizen of the United States.
But Puerto Rico is not a state. It continues to be a territory. Under the U.S. Constitution, Congress has “plenary” – complete – power over Puerto Rico, as is clear by the authority of the unpopular and congressionally created Federal Oversight and Management Board (FOMB). It is legal for Congress to treat Puerto Rico differently from states, and Puerto Ricans do not share in the same rights and responsibilities as their fellow U.S. citizens.
There are no senators or voting congressional representatives for Puerto Rico. The Island has just one non-voting representative in the U.S. Congress. The people of Puerto Rico cannot vote in presidential elections; they have no electors in the Electoral College. Puerto Ricans serve in the U.S. military at higher than average rates and yet they cannot vote for their Commander in Chief. Puerto Ricans fight for democracy around the world and yet do not experience democracy at home.
Puerto Rico is also not a country. While Puerto Rico fields successful sports teams in international sporting events and competes in international beauty pageants, those teams and individuals could also be a part of U.S. delegations. The government of Puerto Rico simply doesn’t have the stature of a nation in the foreign arena, whether at the United Nations, World Bank, or in bilateral discussions with sovereign nations.
And, while the title of Puerto Rico includes the word “commonwealth” (just like the titles of Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Kentucky), that word has no legal meaning in the United States. Puerto Rico is simply a territory belonging to the United States.
Meanwhile, Puerto Rico’s young men and women continue to serve in the U.S. armed forces with distinction. Puerto Ricans are voting for statehood with their feet, moving to the 50 states in record numbers, where they automatically receive the full panoply of democratic rights that are the hallmark of the United States – except in Puerto Rico.
From the Archives
Sign up for our FREE
newsletter and keep up with all the news on Puerto Rico’s status.
Thank you for the information, some of which i was not aware of.
The issue of the future of Puerto Rico and it’s citizens continue to be covered in a cloud of meaningless…
If what you say about PR voting three (3) times for statehood then what is the problem? Could it be…
There is really nothing to discuss. If Puerto Rico wants to be treated on the same level as the states…
There has ALWAYS been anti factions against ANY change in almost everything. That will never change because it is impossible…