Consideration of Puerto Rico Senate’s Status Bill Postponed

The Puerto Rico Senate has delayed consideration of legislation calling for a federally-sponsored referendum on Puerto Rico’s political status. The bill, called “The Law for the Immediate Decolonization of Puerto Rico (S.B. 51), ” was introduced by Thomas Rivera Schatz, President of the Puerto Rico Senate.

The proposal originally set the date for the next Puerto Rico plebiscite as May 28, 2017, but that date appears to be slipping to early June. The options on the ballot in the legislative proposal would be statehood or independence. If independence was the people’s choice, a second vote in September would determine whether Puerto Rico would negotiate an Associated Free State agreement with the United States, or start again as a sovereign independent nation.

The Marshall Islands and Palau are examples of U.S. territories which became Free Associated States, while the Philippines and Cuba are former U.S. possessions which became independent nations. None have U.S. citizenship, and none receive federal resources at Puerto Rico’s current level.

Former governor Alejandro Garcia Padilla had promised to hold the federally authorized vote in 2016, but his party, the “commonwealth” party, was unable to come up with a definition of the “commonwealth” option which they were determined to keep on the ballot. The Department of Justice must approve all ballot options, and has already said that “enhanced commonwealth” is not a viable option under the U.S. Constitution. Influential U.S. decision makers and legal experts have affirmed over the years that “Commonwealth” is “unrealistic,” “deceptive,” “unacceptable, and “unattainable myth.”

The history of plebiscites in Puerto Rico is one of confusion, with a different definition of “Commonwealth” on each ballot.

S.B. 51, which includes only options approved by the U.S. Department of Justice as constitutional, was to have been considered on January 25, 2017, but the senate has now postponed the bill’s consideration indefinitely, according to Caribbean Business. The same source says that the current minority party, the “commonwealth” party, has demanded an opportunity to come up with a “commonwealth” option for the ballot, but that members of that party are complaining that there is no “real proposal to address Puerto Rico’s political reality in relation to the United States.”

The situation is reminiscent of the stalemate in 2014. The idea of “enhanced commonwealth” has been rejected over and over by the U.S. government, but the “commonwealth” party minority continues to insist that this option should be on the ballot. The U.S. government has already stated that the federally-funded plebiscite cannot include any options which are not consistent with the U.S. constitution.

2 Comments

Dennis

I do not believe this is really about a Commonwealth option, but rather an attempt to postpone the status quo, and continue with no change for as long as possible.

Luis Arroyo

Less than one month into the new pro statehood administration & Thomas Shatz has proven to be a liberal democratic hack against his own statehood party, the NPP/PNP.
* He voted against st Julia Keleher for head of PR schools because she didn’t provide a liberal enough excuse & allow trannie bathrooms! She was confirmed anyway.
* Now he bows down to minority Populist Democrats (PPD/PDP) demands to postpone until PPD comes up with a definition for its “Commonwealth” even after US made clear Commonwealth in any form isn’t solution under US Law.
The PPD is only stalling , they will never submit a definition.
This way they’ll cry “We weren’t included”
Already, the PPD is lobbying against the plebiscite in PR AND IN DC. Claiming “statehood vs Separate Sovereignty is A VIOLATION OF CIVIL RIGHTS FOR 50% OF PR WHO REJECT STATEHOOD & INDEPENDENCE ”

This is evil manipulation! The PPD wants a commonwealth thats:
* “Non Territorial” (PR would NOT BE US TERRITORY.)
* Outside the US Territorial Clause (US constitution makes clear this is only possible with statehood & Independence. PPD opposes statehood, falsely calls it “annexation” -to perpetuate the myth they currently are independently sovereign!
* US Federal courts & Associated agencies leave Puerto Rico.

Summary
*No Territorial status ,IOW,PR isn’t US territory.
*No territorial Clause Congressional jurisdiction.
*No Federal Court jurisdiction in PR.

* Internationally recognized & admired in global organizations.

* PPD &PIP CELEBRATING TERRORIST OSCAR LOPEZ RELEASE.
*PPD ADOPTING THE REVOLUTIONARY CUBAN LIGHT BLUE & INCORPORATING IT AS A FAKE “CELESTIAL BLUE” INSIDE THE PR FLAG.

THAT’S INDEPENDENCE “POR LA COCINA” (THRY THE BACK KITCHEN DOOR!)

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.