#Fairness4Territories Breaks the Mold

Territories come up on Twitter roughly every two minutes, according to social media data tool Social Mention. But the tweets are not talking about the territories of Guam, Puerto Rico, or the US Virgin Islands. Twitter mentions of territories are more likely to be about werewolves, video games, or at least Canada. Members of Congress are rarely involved in those conversations.

Recently, however, a new conversation has shown up on Twitter, with the hashtag #Fairness4Territories. Kicked off by Rep. Stacey Plaskett (D-VI), it was apparently inspired by the Supreme Court’s refusal to review Segovia vs. U.S., a case about the inability of the residents of territories to vote in presidential elections.

Social Mention identifies seven unique users of the hashtag, including these members of Congress:

* Stacey Plaskett (D-USVI)
* Barbara Lee (D-CA)
* Yvette Clarke (D-NY)
* Hank Johnson (D-GA)
* Alma Adams (D-NC)
* Carolyn Maloney (D-NY)
* Marcia Fudge (D-OH)

Using a handful of carefully-crafted tweets, the legislators made the case for voting rights for territories belonging to the United States.

One tweet says,

“9 million US citizens in Guam, Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands are denied their voting rights in presidential elections and full representation in Congress. We need #Fairness4Territories — every citizen deserves a voice in our democracy.”

Nine million is clearly inaccurate; the inhabitants of the territories mentioned total fewer than five million. But it is indeed true that these citizens cannot vote in presidential elections and are not fully represented in Congress.

Another tweet in the series:

“American astronauts in space have a special procedure allowing them to vote, and American citizens living abroad can vote absentee, but millions of residents of U.S. territories currently cannot vote for president. #Fairness4Territories #SCOTUS

There have been quite a few retweets and a couple of responses. Jeffrey L. Farrow, a former White House aide and an expert on territorial matters, tweeted,

“The right to vote is the right to equal access to the polls; it’s not a right to voting representation in the U.S. Government. The Constitution limits that right to States, with DC having votes in electing the president through a constitutional amendment.”

Chris Fagan tweeted,

“@StaceyPlaskett Then the Virgin Islands are going to have to become a state. It would be easier to get a simple majority in both chambers for statehood than to get 2/3 of the states to amend the US Constitution to allow territories the same privileges as states.”

Both these responses make the point that the President of the United States is elected by States, through the mechanism of the Electoral College, rather than by individual votes. U.S. citizens from Puerto Rico, for example, can vote as soon as they become residents of a State. U.S. citizens from a State lose their vote as soon as they become residents of Puerto Rico.

Puerto Rico has officially requested statehood, unlike the other territories belonging to the United States. The Virgin Islands held a status referendum in 1993. The voters chose to remain a territory at that time. Plaskett, the representative of the Virgin Islands in Congress, is the only representative of a territory to join in the #Fairness4Territories Twitter effort. The other Members of Congress participating represent States.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.